How To Reheat Stuffed Mushrooms (And Not Stuff It Up!)

Plenty of food lovers adore plump and juicy stuffed mushrooms, whether they are filled to the brim with flavorful vegetables or bubbling over with melted cheese. Stuffed mushrooms are always more enjoyable when they are fresh, but one may end up with leftovers that have been sitting in the fridge overnight. 

While many people believe that reheating mushrooms can make them unsafe for consumption, one can reheat stuffed mushrooms if they have been properly cooked and stored. There are a few ways to reheat and revive stuffed mushrooms without ruining their taste or texture. 

Stuffed mushrooms can be reheated in an oven or toaster oven for the best results. One can use a microwave to reheat stuffed mushrooms, but this method can lead to a dry or rubbery texture. 

How To Reheat Stuffed Mushrooms

Reheating stuffed mushrooms can be quite perplexing, as it is easy to overcook or ruin the texture. The best reheating method will depend on your fillings and whether the stuffed mushrooms are dry or moist. Stuffed mushrooms should always be left to reach room temperature before reheating them for the best results. 

How To Reheat Stuffed Mushrooms In The Oven

Using the oven to reheat stuffed mushrooms is the most fool-proof method, as it generally works very well regardless of the mushrooms’ fillings or moisture content. Using the oven also works great for larger batches of leftover stuffed mushrooms, ensuring each mushroom is equal in temperature and texture. 

To reheat stuffed mushrooms in the oven: 

1. Preheat the oven to 325°F. Preheating can take around 30 minutes, depending on your oven. 
2. Place the stuffed mushrooms on a baking sheet, lightly greased with vegetable oil or butter. This step will ensure that the stuffed mushrooms do not stick to the sheet and break when removed. 
3. If the stuffed mushrooms are moist or soggy, leave them uncovered. If they are dry, wrap the mushrooms with foil, leaving some space between the foil and the mushroom’s toppings. This step will retain moisture while preventing the cheese or fillings from sticking to the foil. 
4. Bake the stuffed mushrooms for 10-15 minutes. Larger batches can take around 20 minutes to reheat properly. 
5. The stuffed mushrooms should have an internal temperature of 165°F before serving. 

How To Reheat Stuffed Mushrooms In A Toaster Oven

Using a toaster oven can offer the best of both worlds – scrumptious leftover stuffed mushrooms and a shorter waiting time. Toaster ovens work well for smaller stuffed mushroom batches. Since they apply even heat, toaster ovens can help achieve a firm exterior topped with beautifully golden melted cheese.

To reheat stuffed mushrooms in a toaster oven:

1. Set the toaster oven to medium heat. Preheating a toaster oven typically takes 5-10 minutes, depending on the make and size. 
2. Wrap the mushrooms with foil, leaving space between the foil and the mushrooms’ toppings. This step will prevent the cheese or fillings from sticking to the foil and help retain moisture since toaster ovens can dry out the mushrooms quickly.  
3. Allow the mushrooms to reheat for 5-10 minutes. 
4. The stuffed mushrooms should have an internal temperature of 165°F before serving.

In terms of appliance suggestions, I do like the Cosori dual toaster oven and air fryer. We just got it recently, I have been using it for a ton of my reheating needs.

How To Reheat Stuffed Mushrooms In The Microwave

Using a microwave to reheat stuffed mushrooms will be far less effective than the previous methods. But, the convenience of using a microwave may be far too tempting to resist, and it can be done with a few simple tricks if you are short on time or kitchen equipment. 

However, it is important to note that one cannot use a microwave for larger batches of stuffed mushrooms. Closely monitor the stuffed mushrooms throughout the process, as letting them reheat for too long can cause them to dry out or become rubbery. 

To reheat stuffed mushrooms in the microwave: 

1. Line a microwave-safe plate with a paper towel to prevent the bottoms from becoming soggy. 
2. Place the mushrooms onto the plate and place a microwave cover over the mushrooms to help them retain moisture. 
3. Place the stuffed mushrooms in the microwave.
4. Reheat the stuffed mushrooms in 30-second intervals until they are hot. Reheating a single serving of stuffed mushrooms in the microwave typically takes 1-2 minutes.
5. Remove the stuffed mushrooms from the microwave once they have reached 165°F. 

Frequently Asked Questions

Do you still have questions about reheating stuffed mushrooms? We’ve got answers!

How Do I Store Reheated Stuffed Mushrooms?

Reheated stuffed mushrooms should be left to reach room temperature before storing them. They should be stored in an airtight container and kept in the refrigerator. Stuffed mushrooms can last for 3-5 days when properly cooked and stored in the fridge. 

Can I Reheat Stuffed Mushrooms Multiple Times? 

One can reheat stuffed mushrooms multiple times if they are still safe for consumption. However, reheating them multiple times is not recommended. Generally, reheating stuffed mushrooms once or twice should retain their enjoyability, but reheating them too many times can cause them to become dry, chewy, rubbery, or hard.

How Long Does It Take To Reheat Stuffed Mushrooms? 

It typically takes around 10 minutes to reheat stuffed mushrooms. Using an oven will take the longest, while using a microwave is the fastest method but will not achieve the best results. Toaster ovens are great options for reheating stuffed mushrooms, with an average of 5-10 minutes for preheating and 5-10 minutes for reheating.